Hostel Backers Glean 2 Appeal Paths
From the September 6, 2007 version of the Provincetown Banner
By Derek Burritt
Banner Staff
EASTHAM-Supporters of the youth hostel on Goody Hallet Drive
showed up by the dozens to Tuesday's board of selectmen meeting,
but unfortunately it's going to take more than a simple show
of community support to keep the 40-year-old hostel open past
Sept. 15.
Over the last couple weeks, Ken Fishman, a Governor Prence
Road resident, began a petition in favor of the hostel that
currently includes more than 400 signatures. While addressing
selectmen and those in attendance, he said that "people couldn't
pick up the pen quickly enough" to sign. Fishman carried out
his campaign and submitted the petition to the town knowing
full well the selectmen don't have the authority to overturn
the zoning board of appeals decision that closed the hostel
in accordance with Eastham zoning bylaws. He said he did it
so the board would know the sentiment of residents, to which
he received thunderous applause from the gathered audience.
Robert Freeman, an abutter on Jeremiah's Look who has acted
as a spokesperson for neighbors, spoke out against allegations
that he's "greedy." He said he's not profiting in any way
from the situation, and he only became concerned with the
hostel when it solicited input from the neighborhood about
plans to expand. During this process, Freeman alleges that
he was "talking to an organization that wasn't listening"
to the concerns of the neighborhood.
Deborah Ruhe, executive director at Hostelling International
USA, said "her heart is full" from the people who came forward
to sign the petition and support the hostel. It was about
a year ago this week that she made her first presentation
to abutters addressing the conceptual expansion. She vowed
"never to show a building concept to anyone again." Selectmen
heard from every side as well as from those in the audience,
who spoke in support of the hostel for a variety of reasons
ranging from its longstanding tradition to the opportunity
it offers foreign workers to live in town cheaply while finding
summer jobs and accommodations. However, at this point, the
issue is a matter of fact and law.
Selectman Dave Schropfer says he believes the ZBA made an
"appropriate decision under the law," and vice chair Martin
McDonald echoed his opinion by saying the hostel is simply
"not in compliance" with town zoning bylaws.
Going forward, the only recourse the hostel has is to appeal
the decision of the ZBA within 20 days of its filing with
the town clerk. As of Tuesday night, no appeal had been filed,
although Ruhe suggested one would be forthcoming. The hostel
will remain closed after Sept. 15 until any future appeal
process is complete. Town Administrator Sheila Vanderhoef
said the only recourse for residents who want to help the
hostel reopen is to get an article for a zoning bylaw change
on the warrant for May's Town Meeting. However, she advised
that any zoning bylaws must be broad in nature and cannot
create "spot zoning."